PSA vs BGS vs CGC: Which Card Grading Company Should You Choose?

· 2 min read

PSA vs BGS vs CGC comes down to the card and your goal: PSA is the most widely recognised for resale, BGS shows sub-grades and half points that suit high-end cards, and CGC is popular for trading card games. All three seal the card in a tamper-evident slab.

If you are new to grades, start with our grading guide, then use this comparison to choose.

PSA vs BGS vs CGC at a Glance

PSABGSCGC
Scale1–10, whole numbers1–10, half points1–10
Sub-gradesNoYes: centering, corners, edges, surfaceShown on some labels
Often chosen forResale and liquidityModern, high-end cardsTCG and comics

Which grading company is best for resale?

PSA slabs are the most commonly traded, so buyers tend to recognise them quickly. That familiarity is the main reason many collectors choose PSA when they plan to sell.

Why do collectors like BGS?

BGS reports four sub-grades, so a buyer sees exactly where a card is strong or weak. A BGS 9.5 is highly regarded, and the sub-grades give extra detail that a single number cannot.

When does CGC make sense?

CGC is well known in comics and has built a strong following in trading card games. Its slabs are compact and easy to read, which many collectors like for display.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is a PSA 9 worth the same as a BGS 9?

Not necessarily. Each company has its own standards and market, so always compare sold prices for the same company and grade.

Can I grade a card more than once?

Yes, some collectors crack a slab and resubmit, but the card can come back lower. Take care when removing it, as damage will count against it.

Does grading guarantee a card is authentic?

Graders authenticate as part of the process, but you should still verify the certificate number on the grader’s own website.

Our advice

Pick the company whose slabs your likely buyers prefer, and grade only cards where the grade clearly adds value. Browse our graded cards to see slabs side by side.

How we prepared this guide: written by the Emakcard team from our experience buying and selling slabs. Check each grader’s website for current scales, fees and turnaround times.